School Transport Appeals
Meeting: 05/09/2013 - Appeals Sub-Committee (Item 12)
12 School Transport Appeals 
PDF 361 KB
The Sub-Committee is asked to determine the following appeals against the decision of the Council not to offer assisted school transport.
A copy of the Home to School Transport policy is attached.
The cases will be heard at the following times:
Case 1: 2.00 pm (pages 37-84)
Case 2: 2.45 pm (pages 85-110)
Additional documents:
- Committee Paper , View reasons restricted (12/2)
- Application , View reasons restricted (12/3)
- Refusal Letter , View reasons restricted (12/4)
- Review Request , View reasons restricted (12/5)
- Review letter , View reasons restricted (12/6)
- Appeal Form 1 , View reasons restricted (12/7)
- Appeal Form 2 , View reasons restricted (12/8)
- Appeal Form 3 , View reasons restricted (12/9)
- Letter of support from Cllr DB 1 , View reasons restricted (12/10)
- Letter of support from Cllr DB 2 , View reasons restricted (12/11)
- Letter of support - CDAFSU , View reasons restricted (12/12)
- Letter of Support - Wimboldsley , View reasons restricted (12/13)
- Letter of Support - Malbank , View reasons restricted (12/14)
- Income - P60 , View reasons restricted (12/15)
- Income - Tax Credits 1 , View reasons restricted (12/16)
- Income - Tax Credits 2 , View reasons restricted (12/17)
- Income - Child Benefit , View reasons restricted (12/18)
- Bills 1 , View reasons restricted (12/19)
- Bills 2 , View reasons restricted (12/20)
- Bills 3 , View reasons restricted (12/21)
- Bills - Solicitors 1 , View reasons restricted (12/22)
- Bills - Solicitors 2 , View reasons restricted (12/23)
- Map , View reasons restricted (12/24)
- Committee Paper 2 , View reasons restricted (12/25)
- Application 2 , View reasons restricted (12/26)
- Refusal letter 2 , View reasons restricted (12/27)
- Spare Seat Offer , View reasons restricted (12/28)
- 05 - Appeal Form 1 , View reasons restricted (12/29)
- 06 - Appeal Form 2 , View reasons restricted (12/30)
- 07 - Appeal Form 3 , View reasons restricted (12/31)
- Request for further information , View reasons restricted (12/32)
- Supporting information 1 , View reasons restricted (12/33)
- Supporting information 2 , View reasons restricted (12/34)
- Financial information , View reasons restricted (12/35)
- Map 2 , View reasons restricted (12/36)
Minutes:
The Sub-Committee considered two appeals against the decision of the Cheshire East Transport Service not to allow assistant school transport in accordance with the Council’s Under 16 School Transport Policy.
Case 1
The appellant attended the hearing. The Sub-Committee heard the appeal based on the oral and written evidence of the Presenting Officer who detailed the Local Authority’s case and the oral and written evidence of the appellant. Members of the Sub Committee asked questions by way of clarification.
The Presenting Officer and the appellant withdrew from the meeting following which the Sub Committee reached its decision.
RESOLVED:
That the appeal be upheld.
Case 2
The Presenting Officer attended the meeting. The Sub-Committee heard the appeal based on the oral and written evidence of the Presenting Officer who detailed the Local Authority’s case and the written evidence of the appellant. Members of the Sub Committee asked questions by way of clarification.
The Presenting Officer withdrew from the meeting following which the Sub Committee reached its decision.
RESOLVED:
That the appeal be upheld.